Quote from: wadesworld on January 20, 2025, 08:05:15 PMDixon is playing a lot better than Kam in Big East games.

As long as Kam picks it back up and Marquette keeps winning, there should be no debate. Plenty of production left to be had in 13 games.

Quote from: GoldenEagles03 on January 20, 2025, 08:00:59 PMNo chance.

If we had to watch Markus lose a POY to Myles Powell because Seton Hall won more...then absolutely not. They lose a lot of games because Dixon does nothing but chuck shots.

Kam produces more points and contributes more to a Top 10 team.

Any evidence that the bolded was the reason?

I think Johnny B and Wadesworld are right as of today. Dixon is better so far this season. We all hope that Kam wins BE POY, but the W/L record of Marquette or Villanova is not a factor as far as I know. If this is not the case, someone please let me know.

Death, taxes, and Neptune finding a way to fail...

Quote from: Scoop Snoop on January 20, 2025, 08:27:50 PMAny evidence that the bolded was the reason?

I think Johnny B and Wadesworld are right as of today. Dixon is better so far this season. We all hope that Kam wins BE POY, but the W/L record of Marquette or Villanova is not a factor as far as I know. If this is not the case, someone please let me know.

Markus had 806 points and 95 assists shooting 41% from 3.

Myles Powell had 589 points and 81 assists shooting 30% from 3.

That's pretty good evidence that more winning matters.

Quote from: CountryRoads on January 20, 2025, 07:19:16 PMUgh now Nova will be extra angry when we play them this week! But that's not a good loss for Neptune..

Now I'm concerned

Quote from: GoldenEagles03 on January 20, 2025, 08:36:52 PMMarkus had 806 points and 95 assists shooting 41% from 3.

Myles Powell had 589 points and 81 assists shooting 30% from 3.

That's pretty good evidence that more winning matters.

No, it is not! Do you know what the factors were or not? My guess is that you don't know. Was it strange? Hell yes!  That does not mean it was because of the W/L records of the two teams. It was not a TOY (team of the year)) award, it was a POY award. Expecting scoopers to take something as factual just because you said it is Muggsy's M.O.

If someone who actually knows how the choice was made comes forth and supports your statement, then I will walk it back.